- 96 Points – Best Cellaring Selection – Zen Master 2012 Centurion Shiraz
- 95 Points - Eddies Old vine Shiraz 2017 Shiraz
- 95 Points – Bachelor 2018 Shiraz
- 95 Points – Boehm's Black 2017 Shiraz
- 95 Points – Eddies Old vine Shiraz 2013 Shiraz
- 95 Points- – Forgotten Hero 2013 Survivor Shiraz
- 95 Points- Zen Master 2013 Centurion Shiraz
- 94 Points - Boehm's Black 2019 Shiraz
- 94 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2018 Shiraz
- 94 Points- – Forgotten Hero 2018 Survivor Vine Shiraz
- 94 Points- – Forgotten Hero 2016 Survivor Vine Shiraz
- 94 Points - The Bachelor 2016 Shiraz
- 94 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2015 Shiraz
- 94 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2006 Shiraz
- 93 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2019 Shiraz
- 93 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2018 Shiraz
- 93 Points - Forgotten Hero 2019 Survivor Vine Shiraz
- 93 Points - Boehm's Black 2016 Shiraz
- 93 Points - Secret drop 2015 Cabernet Sauvignon
- 93 Points – The Bachelor 2017 Shiraz
- 92 Points - Indulgent 2023 Grenache
- 92 Points - The Giant 2020 Durif
- 92 Points - The Giant 2019 Durif
- 92 Points - The Giant 2013 Durif
- 92 Points - The Giant 2014 Durif
- 92 Points – The Mob 2017 Montepulciano
- 92 Points - Wild Rose 2017 Vermentino
- 92 Points - A Label 2016 Cabernet Sauvignon
- 92 Points – The Mob 2017 Montepulciano
- 92 Points – The Mob 2015 Montepulciano
- 92 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2005 Shiraz
- 92 Points – The Bachelor 2012 Shiraz
- 92 Points – The Bachelor 2013 Shiraz
- 91 Points – The Bachelor 2015 Shiraz
- 91 Points – The Bachelor 2020 Shiraz
- 91 Points – The Bachelor 2006 Shiraz
- 91 Points – John and Barb's Old Vine 2019 Grenache
- 91 Points – The Mob 2018 Montepulciano
- 91 Points - The Giant 2017 Durif
- 91 Points - The Giant 2018 Durif
- 91 Points – Eddies Old Vine 2005 Shiraz
- 91 Points - A Label 2016 Shiraz
- 90 Points – 2014 Vermentino
- 90 Points – 2015 Vermentino
- 90 Points – 2016 Vermentino
- 90 Points – 2018 Vermentino
- 90 Points - Opulent 2020 Shiraz
- 90 Points - Mob 2019 Montepulciano
- James Halliday – Top 10 Dark Horse Winery 2017